Comments on track a1 draft tariff language

Extended day-ahead market ISO balancing authority area participation rules

Print
Comment period
Sep 01, 12:30 pm - Sep 14, 05:00 pm
Submitting organizations
View by:

San Diego Gas & Electric
Submitted 09/14/2023, 04:22 pm

Contact

Teresa Silva (tsilva@sdge.com)

1. Please provide a summary of your organization’s comments on the EDAM ISO BAA Participation Rules track A1 draft tariff language:

SDG&E appreciates the opportunity to comment on the Extended Day-Ahead Market ISO Balancing Authority Area Participation Rules. Overall SDG&E is supportive of this initiative with a few issues remaining included in the final proposal comments. SDG&E noted the stressed system hours identified in the final proposal, 4pm-9pm is missing from the draft tariff language and suggests adding these to the tariff language to reflect when the net export constraint will apply. Additional questions regarding the specific tariff language below are detailed below:

2. Provide any redline changes and embedded comments on Section 11 – CAISO Settlements and Billing and all related subsections as an attachment to this comment template, and provide any additional comments on section 11 in the text box below:
When providing additional comments in the text box below, please specify the subsection(s) your comments refer to.

Section

Draft Tariff Language

Concern

11.35.1.2.1  Settlement of CAISO Transfer System Resources

the CAISO will net all CAISO EIM Transfer System Resources on an hourly basis, subtracting the applicable EIM Transfer revenue, and then allocate all such revenue, or surcharge, to Scheduling Coordinators with the allocation ratio determined as the individual Scheduling Coordinator’s metered Demand for that hour divided by the total CAISO metered Demand for that hour excluding balanced ETC/TOR metered demand. 

The terms "measured demand" and "metered demand" are used in sections 11.35.1.2.1 and 11.35.2.1.2. It is unclear if these are referring to the same concept, we
suggest the CAISO clarify or use the same term if there referring to the same demand.

11.35.2.1.2  Remaining Rights in Support of EDAM Transfers

To Scheduling Coordinators for Existing Contract rights and Transmission Ownership Rights holders that exercised their rights based on the individual proportion of scheduled transmission rights supporting the EDAM Transfer, with the remainder, if any, allocated pro rata to Scheduling Coordinators based on Measured Demand excluding Demand associated with balanced ETC/TOR Self-Schedules.

3. Provide any redline changes and embedded comments on Section 26 – Transmission Rates and Charges and all related subsections as an attachment to this comment template, and provide any additional comments on section 26 in the text box below:
When providing additional comments in the text box below, please specify the subsection(s) your comments refer to.

No Comment 

4. Provide any redline changes and embedded comments on Section 27 – CAISO Markets and Processes and all related subsections as an attachment to this comment template, and provide any additional comments on section 27 in the text box below:
When providing additional comments in the text box below, please specify the subsection(s) your comments refer to.

Section

Draft Tariff Language

Concern

27.14.3.1 Confidence Factor

If there is observed risk
of non-performance or non-delivery by Supply overall or from intertie schedules, or if Good Utility Practice or operator judgement otherwise requires, then the CAISO Balancing Authority Area will utilize a tunable confidence factor of less than 100% configurable by hour, as provided in Section 33.31.3.1, and consistent with the process set forth in the Business Practice Manual. 

The term "Operator judgement"
 is vague, examples would help define this term

27.14.3.2 Additional Reliability Margin

If there is an observed risk that additional
capacity will be needed to respond to reliability conditions, or if Good Utility Practice or operator judgement otherwise requires, then the CAISO will utilize an additional tunable reliability margin configurable by hour, as provided in Section 33.31.3.2, and consistent with the process set forth in the Business Practice Manual. 

The terms "Good utility practice" and "operator judgement" are vague, examples would help make this clearer

5. Provide any additional comments on the EDAM ISO BAA Participation Rules track A1 draft tariff language:

Southern California Edison
Submitted 09/14/2023, 04:03 pm

Contact

John Diep (John.diep@sce.com)

1. Please provide a summary of your organization’s comments on the EDAM ISO BAA Participation Rules track A1 draft tariff language:

SCE has reviewed the tariff language for the three sections 11, 26, and 27 relating to the specifics of how EDAM applies to the ISO and its individual Participating TOs, particularly relating to allocations of EDAM amounts of revenue or costs to individual PTOs or ETC/TOR entities.  SCE believes the tariff language reflects the Track A1 Final Proposal and has identified only one instance where SCE proposes a tariff language change, relating to the internal allocation of CAISO-wide Excess Wheel-Through Recoverable Revenue (see item 3 below).

2. Provide any redline changes and embedded comments on Section 11 – CAISO Settlements and Billing and all related subsections as an attachment to this comment template, and provide any additional comments on section 11 in the text box below:
When providing additional comments in the text box below, please specify the subsection(s) your comments refer to.

SCE has no comments on this section. 

3. Provide any redline changes and embedded comments on Section 26 – Transmission Rates and Charges and all related subsections as an attachment to this comment template, and provide any additional comments on section 26 in the text box below:
When providing additional comments in the text box below, please specify the subsection(s) your comments refer to.

Excess Wheel-Through Recoverable Revenue is a collective ISO BAA calculation by definition, since there is a single determination of CAISO imports and exports, considering all ISO BAA Scheduling Points, and which are netted against each other.  SCE does not see how that can be divided up to each PTO directly based on a PTO specific calculation, as the following tariff language states: 

 

26.2.1.3 Excess Wheel-Through Recoverable Revenue   

The individual excess wheel-through recoverable revenue is an annual calculation of the twelve (12) monthly aggregations from the prior year, with each month calculated as the product of (a) the excess wheel through quantity computed as the total export transfer quantity in MWh from the CAISO Balancing Authority Area less the total import transfer quantity in MWh into the CAISO Balancing Authority Area, bounded from below by zero, and (b) the applicable regional or local wheeling access rate of the  applicable transmission owner for the transfer location in effect at the time of the annual calculation. 

 

SCE proposes that this component of the Recoverable Revenue should be allocated to PTOs on the basis of Gross Load.  If the CAISO intends to directly determine an Excess Wheel-Through Recoverable Revenue for each PTO directly, the calculation description should be more clearly stated.  For example, it is unclear how the transfer locations to be used in the calculation are to be determined.  Is there only one for each PTO, and if so, which one?

4. Provide any redline changes and embedded comments on Section 27 – CAISO Markets and Processes and all related subsections as an attachment to this comment template, and provide any additional comments on section 27 in the text box below:
When providing additional comments in the text box below, please specify the subsection(s) your comments refer to.

SCE has no comments on this section.

5. Provide any additional comments on the EDAM ISO BAA Participation Rules track A1 draft tariff language:

SCE has no additional comments.

Back to top