1.
Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.
ACP-California (ACP-CA) appreciates the opportunity to comment on CAISO’s Draft 2027- 2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap. ACP-CA generally supports the roadmap and appreciates CAISO’s willingness to take on substantive infrastructure policy issues in the coming years, including updating transmission planning coordination, large load issues, interconnection process enhancements, and reforms to Maximum Import Capability (MIC).
ACP-California offers the following suggestions for CAISO’s consideration as it scopes Interconnection Process Enhancements (IPE) 6.0 and considers potential updates to the transmission planning Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) among CAISO, the CPUC, and the CEC.
1. Interconnection Process Enhancements 6.0
ACP-CA recommends that CAISO consider three key areas when scoping the issues to address in IPE 6.0.
First, ACP-CA supports including the stakeholder-submitted topics identified in the October 15th update presentation, including streamlined augmentation of operational batteries, and opportunities for Energy Only resources to obtain deliverability. These topics have been identified by stakeholders as important and ACP-California supports their inclusion in the scope of IPE 6.
Second, we urge CAISO to resolve – if not addressed sooner – issues that have been identified through development of the Resource Interconnection Standards (RIS) BPM. In particular, there have been unexpected interpretations of deposit requirements, withdrawal penalties, and eligibility for penalty-free withdrawal that have arisen from CAISO in the RIS BPM which appear to conflict with the plain language of the tariff. Interconnection customers need clear, consistent rules governing the interaction among commercial readiness deposits, Generator Interconnection (GIA) deposits, and construction security, and they need that certainty as quickly as possible. CAISO should promptly address inconsistencies with the tariff and use IPE 6.0 to resolve underlying policy questions requiring further consideration.
Finally, ACP-California asks that CAISO also include consideration of broader reforms in IPE 6.0 to better streamline the interconnection process and address challenges that have arisen as experience with the new process has been gained. This should include reconsideration of the sequencing and timing of key milestones and customer responsibilities, informed by implementation experience and process improvements identified to date. For example, CAISO should revisit the current requirement for generators to execute GIAs before knowing whether they have received a Transmission Plan Deliverability allocation in their first chance to request TPD. This and other sequencing issues warrant review to better align customer commitments and financial exposure with the information available to assess project viability.
2. CAISO–CPUC–CEC Transmission Planning MOU
ACP-California understands that the CAISO’s proposed initiative to update the Transmission Planning MOU is driven by the need to implement AB 2111 (2026). We also believe it is timely to evaluate the MOU-driven TPP-IRP norms in preparation for a transition to 2-year TPP planning cycle and to adapt to recent experience with transmission planning outcomes and application of the interconnection processes post-IPE. AB 2111 directs the CPUC to “provide transmission-focused guidance to the Independent System Operator about resource portfolios of expected future renewable energy resources and zero-carbon resources that takes into account uncertainty and optionality, is risk prudent, and supports compliance with Federal Energy Regulatory Commission orders,” with various specifications, as described below
- 454.57 (d)(2)(A) Provide an allocation of the renewable energy and zero-carbon resources by region based on consideration of technical feasibility and commercial interest in each region to allow the Independent System Operator to identify and approve transmission facilities needed to interconnect resources and reliably serve the needs of load centers.
In light of this directive, ACP-California recommends the CAISO work with the Commission to reconsider assessments of commercial interest in the TPP and busbar mapping process. This should include evaluation of merchant service interconnection requests, interconnection requests that are submitted but do not pass the zonal screening process or otherwise drop out, and additional indications of commercial interest outside the interconnection queue process, including site control, engineering design, contracting status, and permit applications, all of which indicate some level of financial commitment from a developer in a project. ACP-California looks forward to providing further recommendations on how commercial interest evaluation could be improved as part of this initiative.
We also see an opportunity for the CAISO to consider EDAM benefits (e.g., reduced congestion, increased transfer capacity) in its evaluation and potential approval of transmission upgrades in the TPP process.
- 454.57 (d)(2)(C) Evaluate candidate planning decisions via a stress testing process through which the cost and reliability of the electrical system and the implications for future planning decisions and flexibility to support the resource portfolios are assessed, and, in a new or existing proceeding, examine the costs and risks of each candidate planning decision.
Given recent experience with the cancellation of the Serrano Del Amo – Mesa project and the resulting reliability and deliverability deficiencies within the large Mira Loma Mesa constraint, ACP-California believes this directive provides an opportunity for CAISO to develop a TPP policy for addressing major project cancellations driven by cost-increases or feasibility concerns rather than a change in project need. We expect the Serrano Del Amo-Mesa cancellation may not be an isolated occurrence given increases in major equipment costs as well as utility capital constraints. In development of this policy, the CAISO should consider with stakeholders: 1) How should CAISO prioritize project alternatives based on both the reliability and policy-driven purposes for which the original project was approved?; 2) How should the CAISO balance consideration of costs, expediency, and reliability and deliverability benefits in deciding between proposed alternatives?; 3) How should CAISO evaluate and potentially compensate storage resources procured as alternative to wires-based solutions following a project cancelation?
In addition, the CAISO should work with the Commission to continue to refine and validate TPP portfolio choices that are the basis of CAISO’s policy and reliability assessments in the TPP. As CAISO articulated in its comments on the ALJ’s busbar mapping ruling, “Where mapped storage allows the CAISO to avoid or defer significant transmission investment, there must be a reasonable and supportable expectation that the storage will develop in the locations and quantities necessary to meet the identified system need.”[1]
- 454.57 (d)(2)(E) Request that the Independent System Operator approve transmission projects that align with this guidance and that the commission finds to be reasonable in supporting any of the resource portfolios submitted pursuant to subparagraph (D).
ACP-California interprets this directive as opening up the potential for CAISO to approve transmission upgrades identified as needed to support non-base case portfolios. The CAISO should consider the evaluation criteria it would apply to potentially recommend approval of upgrades outside the base case. We also see opportunities under this directive to consider other related transmission planning reforms, such as the potential to formalize a “policy-driven study requests,” opportunities to further support SPTO projects through reservation of deliverability within the CAISO system for subscribers, and improvement in the clarity and consistency in the Commission’s direction to the CAISO regarding out-of-state resources.
- 454.57 (d)(2) (G) Include in this guidance any supplemental or accelerated transmission needs, beyond the requirements of an individual resource portfolio.
ACP-California recommends utilizing this guidance to consider how to better align the CAISO’s 20-year outlook analysis into the TPP process. This could include applying “20-year outlook” criteria in the evaluation of transmission upgrades across multiple resource portfolios and a retroactive screen in each TPP cycle that identifies projects from 20-year outlook (+ any additional “long term” needs) that are left unapproved and an analysis of why the TPP has not identified the upgrade for approval in that cycle.
[1] https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Efile/G000/M627/K962/627962683.PDF, p. 2