Comments on 2026 Draft Infrastructure Policy Roadmap and 10/15 Stakeholder Meeting

2026 Infrastructure policy catalog and roadmap process

Print
Comment period
Oct 16, 02:00 pm - Nov 16, 05:00 pm
Submitting organizations
View by:

American Clean Power - California
Submitted 11/16/2026, 03:12 pm

Contact

Molly Croll, mcroll@cleanpower.org

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

ACP-California (ACP-CA) appreciates the opportunity to comment on CAISO’s Draft 2027- 2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap. ACP-CA generally supports the roadmap and appreciates CAISO’s willingness to take on substantive infrastructure policy issues in the coming years, including updating transmission planning coordination, large load issues, interconnection process enhancements, and reforms to Maximum Import Capability (MIC).  

ACP-California offers the following suggestions for CAISO’s consideration as it scopes Interconnection Process Enhancements (IPE) 6.0 and considers potential updates to the transmission planning Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) among CAISO, the CPUC, and the CEC.

1. Interconnection Process Enhancements 6.0

ACP-CA recommends that CAISO consider three key areas when scoping the issues to address in IPE 6.0.

First, ACP-CA supports including the stakeholder-submitted topics identified in the October 15th update presentation, including streamlined augmentation of operational batteries, and opportunities for Energy Only resources to obtain deliverability. These topics have been identified by stakeholders as important and ACP-California supports their inclusion in the scope of IPE 6.

Second, we urge CAISO to resolve – if not addressed sooner – issues that have been identified through development of the Resource Interconnection Standards (RIS) BPM. In particular, there have been unexpected interpretations of deposit requirements, withdrawal penalties, and eligibility for penalty-free withdrawal that have arisen from CAISO in the RIS BPM which appear to conflict with the plain language of the tariff. Interconnection customers need clear, consistent rules governing the interaction among commercial readiness deposits, Generator Interconnection (GIA) deposits, and construction security, and they need that certainty as quickly as possible. CAISO should promptly address inconsistencies with the tariff and use IPE 6.0 to resolve underlying policy questions requiring further consideration.

Finally, ACP-California asks that CAISO also include consideration of broader reforms in IPE 6.0 to better streamline the interconnection process and address challenges that have arisen as experience with the new process has been gained. This should include reconsideration of the sequencing and timing of key milestones and customer responsibilities, informed by implementation experience and process improvements identified to date. For example, CAISO should revisit the current requirement for generators to execute GIAs before knowing whether they have received a Transmission Plan Deliverability allocation in their first chance to request TPD. This and other sequencing issues warrant review to better align customer commitments and financial exposure with the information available to assess project viability.

 

2. CAISO–CPUC–CEC Transmission Planning MOU

ACP-California understands that the CAISO’s proposed initiative to update the Transmission Planning MOU is driven by the need to implement AB 2111 (2026). We also believe it is timely to evaluate the MOU-driven TPP-IRP norms in preparation for a transition to 2-year TPP planning cycle and to adapt to recent experience with transmission planning outcomes and application of the interconnection processes post-IPE. AB 2111 directs the CPUC to “provide transmission-focused guidance to the Independent System Operator about resource portfolios of expected future renewable energy resources and zero-carbon resources that takes into account uncertainty and optionality, is risk prudent, and supports compliance with Federal Energy Regulatory Commission orders,” with various specifications, as described below

 

  • 454.57 (d)(2)(A) Provide an allocation of the renewable energy and zero-carbon resources by region based on consideration of technical feasibility and commercial interest in each region to allow the Independent System Operator to identify and approve transmission facilities needed to interconnect resources and reliably serve the needs of load centers.

 

In light of this directive, ACP-California recommends the CAISO work with the Commission to reconsider assessments of commercial interest in the TPP and busbar mapping process. This should include evaluation of merchant service interconnection requests, interconnection requests that are submitted but do not pass the zonal screening process or otherwise drop out, and additional indications of commercial interest outside the interconnection queue process, including site control, engineering design, contracting status, and permit applications, all of which indicate some level of financial commitment from a developer in a project. ACP-California looks forward to providing further recommendations on how commercial interest evaluation could be improved as part of this initiative.

 

We also see an opportunity for the CAISO to consider EDAM benefits (e.g., reduced congestion, increased transfer capacity) in its evaluation and potential approval of transmission upgrades in the TPP process.

 

  • 454.57 (d)(2)(C) Evaluate candidate planning decisions via a stress testing process through which the cost and reliability of the electrical system and the implications for future planning decisions and flexibility to support the resource portfolios are assessed, and, in a new or existing proceeding, examine the costs and risks of each candidate planning decision.

 

Given recent experience with the cancellation of the Serrano Del Amo – Mesa project and the resulting reliability and deliverability deficiencies within the large Mira Loma Mesa constraint, ACP-California believes this directive provides an opportunity for CAISO to develop a TPP policy for addressing major project cancellations driven by cost-increases or feasibility concerns rather than a change in project need. We expect the Serrano Del Amo-Mesa cancellation may not be an isolated occurrence given increases in major equipment costs as well as utility capital constraints. In development of this policy, the CAISO should consider with stakeholders: 1) How should CAISO prioritize project alternatives based on both the reliability and policy-driven purposes for which the original project was approved?; 2) How should the CAISO balance consideration of costs, expediency, and reliability and deliverability benefits in deciding between proposed alternatives?; 3) How should CAISO evaluate and potentially compensate storage resources procured as alternative to wires-based solutions following a project cancelation?

 

In addition, the CAISO should work with the Commission to continue to refine and validate TPP portfolio choices that are the basis of CAISO’s policy and reliability assessments in the TPP. As CAISO articulated in its comments on the ALJ’s busbar mapping ruling, “Where mapped storage allows the CAISO to avoid or defer significant transmission investment, there must be a reasonable and supportable expectation that the storage will develop in the locations and quantities necessary to meet the identified system need.”[1]

 

  • 454.57 (d)(2)(E) Request that the Independent System Operator approve transmission projects that align with this guidance and that the commission finds to be reasonable in supporting any of the resource portfolios submitted pursuant to subparagraph (D).

 

ACP-California interprets this directive as opening up the potential for CAISO to approve transmission upgrades identified as needed to support non-base case portfolios. The CAISO should consider the evaluation criteria it would apply to potentially recommend approval of upgrades outside the base case. We also see opportunities under this directive to consider other related transmission planning reforms, such as the potential to formalize a “policy-driven study requests,” opportunities to further support SPTO projects through reservation of deliverability within the CAISO system for subscribers, and improvement in the clarity and consistency in the Commission’s direction to the CAISO regarding out-of-state resources.

 

  • 454.57 (d)(2) (G) Include in this guidance any supplemental or accelerated transmission needs, beyond the requirements of an individual resource portfolio.

 

ACP-California recommends utilizing this guidance to consider how to better align the CAISO’s 20-year outlook analysis into the TPP process. This could include applying “20-year outlook” criteria in the evaluation of transmission upgrades across multiple resource portfolios and a retroactive screen in each TPP cycle that identifies projects from 20-year outlook (+ any additional “long term” needs) that are left unapproved and an analysis of why the TPP has not identified the upgrade for approval in that cycle.

 

 


[1] https://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/PublishedDocs/Efile/G000/M627/K962/627962683.PDF, p. 2

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

ACP-California believes that the 2027-29 infrastructure policy roadmap is ambitious. We will struggle to provide adequate resources to support all of the initiatives identified. Nevertheless, we believe all of the identified initiatives are important and should be pursued. We encourage CAISO to ensure it has sufficient staff support to undertake these initiatives and to also seek to reduce work in other initiatives/areas where there is less stakeholder support for pursuing reforms.

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

No comments at this time.

California Community Choice Association
Submitted 11/16/2026, 12:24 pm

Contact

Shawn-Dai Linderman (shawndai@cal-cca.org)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

The California Community Choice Association (CalCCA) supports the draft 2027-2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap (Draft Roadmap). The Draft Roadmap is representative of stakeholder priorities, including CalCCA’s proposed Energy-Only (EO) to deliverability pathway and the Joint Parties’ Maximum Import Capability (MIC) enhancements initiatives. CalCCA appreciates the CAISO’s responsiveness to stakeholders, and recommends the CAISO adopt the Draft Roadmap for 2027-2029 as proposed.

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

CalCCA has the resources and capacity to support policy initiatives outlined in the Draft Roadmap.  

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

CalCCA has no comments at this time.  

California Department of Water Resources
Submitted 11/16/2026, 03:10 pm

Contact

Geoff Gong (geoff.gong@water.ca.gov)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

DWR-SWP does not oppose the initiatives CAISO has included in the draft 2027-2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap.

However, the omission of the Transmission Access Charge (TAC) Structure Enhancements from the CAISO’s Draft 2027-2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap raises a concern that transmission cost allocation continues to be deferred. The Department of Water Resources-State Water Project (DWR-SWP) respectfully requests and recommends that the CAISO include the TAC structure Enhancements as a priority initiative in its 2027-2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap because it is an important transmission cost allocation issue. Doing so would provide stakeholders supporting this initiative with an opportunity to engage in more in-depth technical discussions and demonstrate the potential benefits of the proposed enhancements to the CAISO market. At a minimum, establishing a dedicated working group would be a meaningful first step toward advancing this important issue.

As DWR-SWP mentioned in its comments filed with CAISO on May 15, 2026, DWR-SWP believes that the TAC Structure Enhancements with a hybrid TAC design is a critical step forward for the CAISO market for the following reasons:

- It is consistent with the principles of cost causation.  CAISO’s existing volumetric-only TAC structure results in cost shifts among transmission customers

- Other ISOs use peak demand contribution to assess transmission charges     

 - Adding a temporal element to the TAC structure would send economic signals encouraging market participants to increasingly move load away from peak demand to reduce their transmission cost.  Lowering peak demand would reduce the need for new transmission infrastructure development which would reduce costs to all

- More accurate price signals would enhance system reliability as reduced peak demand would ease the physical strain on current facilities, leading to decreased maintenance and replacement of transmission facilities and savings for all

- The hybrid TAC design is consistent with CAISO’s allocation of annual Local Capacity Requirement for each TAC area to LSEs based on their coincident peak load 

CAISO previously conducted substantial stakeholder engagement and technical analysis on TAC Structure Enhancements, culminating in a 2018 Draft Final Proposal that considered a hybrid billing methodology incorporating both volumetric energy usage and coincident peak demand. Although the initiative was eventually placed on hold, that deferral should not be interpreted as a determination that the cost allocation concerns have been resolved.

At the October 15, 2026 Stakeholder Meeting, CAISO said it does not hear a strong, consistent stakeholder voice for TAC changes, but also that it hears stakeholders want TAC reformed. Support for TAC Structure Enhancements extends beyond the parties that submitted the proposal:

- In CAISO’s prioritization survey, four parties, including Calpine, rated TAC Structure Enhancements a high priority, the fourth most of the eight proposals. TAC Structure Enhancements received more high-priority ratings than four of the other proposals, yet CAISO directed three of those four to existing processes and did not assign TAC Structure Enhancements to any initiative or process.

- In the 2026 Regional Issues Forum (RIF) Roundtable Report (April 22, 2026), the Consumer-Owned Utilities sector listed completing the TAC Structure Enhancement initiative as a new initiative priority. The Independent Power Producers and Marketers sector also listed it among its high priority issues

Furthermore, at the October 15, 2026 Stakeholder Meeting, CAISO mentioned that it is monitoring CPUC ratemaking proposal. However, DWR-SWP believes that CAISO should distinguish FERC-jurisdictional transmission cost allocation from CPUC-jurisdictional retail ratemaking because the CPUC’s authority over retail electric service and retail rate design is distinct from FERC’s authority over transmission rates and that CPUC-approved tariffs do not establish appropriate allocation of transmission network update costs among transmission customers.  Therefore, reliance on CPUC’s retail ratemaking rules does not guarantee that the resulting transmission rates are just and reasonable or not duly discriminatory or preferential.      

In its May comments, CPUC staff stated that the impact of TAC reform “should be considered in combination with retail rate design changes” in the California Advanced Electric Rate Design proceeding (R.26-04-009). DWR-SWP reads that as a request to coordinate the two efforts, not to wait on one before starting the other. DWR-SWP asks CAISO to explain what outcome in the CPUC proceeding would lead it to take up TAC.

Ultimately, DWR-SWP recognizes that the TAC Structure Enhancements initiative involves complex questions concerning cost causation, rate design, and transmission costs allocation. Accordingly, DWR-SWP recommends that the CAISO include TAC Structure Enhancements in the 2027-2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap, with a defined schedule for stakeholder engagement and policy development.  

If CAISO does not add TAC Structure Enhancements to the final roadmap, DWR-SWP requests, at a minimum, that CAISO commit to including the TAC Enhancements in the 2027 roadmap cycle On October 15, CAISO said it will revisit TAC if a need emerges but gave no timeline. Without a defined commitment, TAC could remain deferred indefinitely.

CAISO also plans to update its 2017 white paper on how TAC works today. DWR-SWP requests that CAISO share a draft for stakeholder review and comment before finalizing it. DWR-SWP also asks CAISO to include the updated assessment of the hybrid design’s projected cost impacts that Six Cities requested, so that all parties start a TAC initiative with the same information.

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

DWR-SWP has the resources and capacity to participate in the initiatives on the draft roadmap that affect the State Water Project, DWR-SWP will also review and comment on CAISO’s update to its TAC white paper. 

 

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

For the reasons mentioned in Question #1, DWR-SWP recommends that the CAISO include TAC Structure Enhancements in the 2027-2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap, with a defined schedule for stakeholder engagement and policy development.  

DWR-SWP offers the following feedback on this year’s process and the 2027 process:

-At the start of each roadmap cycle, before stakeholders develop and submit proposals, CAISO should publish (1) the number of new initiatives; (2) how much capacity its non-discretionary and CAISO-initiated items will use; and (3) the capacity remaining for stakeholder proposals. Because CAISO does not carry declined proposals forward, stakeholders must resubmit them in the next cycle and start over. Knowing the CAISO capacity upfront would let stakeholders focus on proposals that can realistically move forward and let the CAISO spend less time reviewing proposals it cannot take up at this time. When the CAISO declines a proposal, it should state whether the decision is based on merit or capacity.

- CAISO describes the catalog and roadmap process as a way to solicit stakeholder proposals and assess stakeholder support. Of the eight stakeholder proposals, one, Maximum Import Capability enhancements, became a roadmap item, and CAISO allocated five to existing initiatives and processes. CAISO’s own additions make up most of the rest of the roadmap. If existing processes can address most proposals, it is unclear what purpose the roadmap process serves for stakeholders

- DWR-SWP asks CAISO to publish the criteria, beyond stakeholder rankings, that it uses to decide which proposals become roadmap items. When CAISO declines a proposal, it should explain why and identify the conditions or timing under which it would reconsider

- The proposed 2027 process leaves CAISO’s non-discretionary items out of the prioritization survey. Showing those items and their expected resource needs in the survey would help stakeholders understand the tradeoffs and rank proposals with that context

- CAISO should reserve capacity in each roadmap cycle for stakeholder proposals, so the process delivers on its purpose of responding to stakeholder priorities

- The 2026 RIF Roundtable Report noted that submissions such as TAC and MIC needed CAISO direction on which roadmap is appropriate. Under the proposed single intake, CAISO should tell submitters early which path a proposal is assigned to and why.

California Energy Storage Alliance (CESA)
Submitted 11/16/2026, 12:24 pm

Contact

Donald Tretheway (donald.tretheway@gdsassociates.com)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

The California Energy Storage Alliance (CESA) appreciates the opportunity to comment on the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.  CESA supports the Interconnection Process Enhancements (IPE) 6.0 initiative planed for policy development completion by the end of Q2 2027.  CESA supports including the two relevant catalog topics submitted by stakeholders within the IPE 6.0 scope: (1) streamlined augmentation of operational batteries and (2) deliverability for energy only resources.  CESA requests the IPE 6.0 scope be expanded to address policy issues arising from the Resource Interconnection Standards business practice manual development.  The following topics should be addressed through IPE 6.0:  (1) GIA execution timing before TPD Allocation, (2) zero-penalty withdrawals, (3) network upgrade liability limitation to 100% of allocated cost, and (4) other topics as needed.  

 

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Yes

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

No additional feedback.

California Public Utilities Commission - Energy Division
Submitted 11/16/2026, 02:13 pm

Contact

David Withrow (David.Withrow@cpuc.ca.gov)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Energy Division Staff (ED Staff or Staff) of the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) develop and administer energy policy and programs to serve the public interest, advise the CPUC, and ensure compliance with CPUC decisions and statutory mandates. ED Staff provide objective and expert analysis that promote reliable, safe, and environmentally sound energy services at just and reasonable rates for the people of California.[1] Further, Staff advocate on behalf of California ratepayers at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), under whose jurisdiction CAISO’s transmission planning falls. 

ED Staff appreciate this opportunity to comment on the 2026 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap, CAISO’s plan on scope and timing of stakeholder initiatives.  ED Staff support CAISO’s roadmap, as indicated by the limited comments here.

Transmission Planning, Delivery, and MOU Coordination

ED Staff will remain engaged in the work to implement FERC Order 1920. We greatly value the collaborative interaction between the CPUC’s Integrated Resource Planning work and the CAISO’s transmission planning and interconnection processes; these linkages bring value to ratepayers as the State of California continues to make significant progress toward its goals for a carbon-free electricity grid. 

Included in this work will be to ensure that the new cadence of the comprehensive transmission planning process (i.e., the current TPP) moving to every 2 years takes full advantage of the two-year window to more effectively vet cost estimates and in-services dates, and to take the opportunity to more fully assess the ongoing need for previously approved projects. ED Staff also look forward to working with CAISO on the annual reliability assessments, which are still part of the new planning process, as the recent use of concurrences for load-related upgrades appears to lack the rigorous assessment Staff believe is needed for such projects. CPUC Staff look forward to working with CAISO to ensure that the annual reliability assessment includes the inputs, assumptions, studies, determination of transmission needs, and approval of transmission solutions triggered by large load customers.

CPUC Staff and many stakeholders continue to focus on ways to improve the validity of timelines for transmission upgrades that impact interconnection of new resources.  CPUC Staff look forward to continuing to work with the CAISO in the context of the Transmission Development Forum, CPUC’s SB 1174 annual assessment, as well as the new Transmission Development Monitor required within the CPUC, pursuant to AB 2493 (Petrie-Norris, 2026), which will provide more binding monitoring and efforts to unify data among the CPUC, CAISO, and CEC.

CPUC staff further anticipate coordinating throughout 2027 with CEC and CAISO staff to update the Memorandum of Understanding that has guided long-term planning for California’s electricity infrastructure since December 2022. Staff note that AB 2111 (Papan, 2026) requires this update to be completed by January 1, 2028.

Large Load Interconnection Study

ED Staff support the CAISO continuing the work to develop and implement changes to its FERC tariff in collaboration with the participating transmission owners (PTO) in response to FERC’s Order to Show Cause (OSC) in FERC Docket EL26-71.  FERC directed CAISO and the PTOs to address five areas of tariff changes: 1. Transmission service application and study processes, including the consideration of alternative transmission technologies; 2. Prevention of cost shifts, and transparency into transmission costs; 3. Co-location and behind-the-meter generation; 4. New transmission services for flexible large loads; and 5. A study process for generation facilities that serve “electrically proximate” large loads and co-located loads.  With formal responsive filings expected from the CAISO and PTOs at FERC on November 16th, ED Staff anticipate that significant work will remain well into 2027 for the CAISO to meet FERC’s directives in the OSC, coordinate with the PTOs, and implement the new tariff provisions.

Interconnection Process Enhancements

ED Staff support consideration of innovative pathways for attaining deliverability status for resources already established as Energy Only, and who have potential to contribute further to the state’s policy goals. CPUC staff support pursuing these concepts as soon as possible within an IPE 6.0 process, with additional process changes relevant to Cluster 17 to be considered, if needed.   

[1] More information about the CPUC Energy Division is available at: https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/about-cpuc/divisions/energy-division

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Yes, Energy Division has the resources to support participation in the initiatives outlined in the infrastructure policy roadmap. 

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

ED Staff agree that the separation of the two roadmaps based on which board governs the initiatives makes sense for 2027. It makes sense to separate initiatives that are expected to be governed by the CAISO Board of Governos such as resource adequacy and infrastructure issues from the market policy initiatives that will be governed by the Western Energy Markets Governing Body in 2027 and the Regional Organization for Western Energy Board of Directors expected in 2028.
      

 

Clean Coalition
Submitted 11/16/2026, 05:56 pm

Contact

Ben Schwartz (ben@clean-coalition.org)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Clean Coalition strongly recommends that CAISO add TAC Structure Enhancements as a dedicated initiative in the 2027–2029 Infrastructure Policy Roadmap. Although TAC reform was explicitly proposed by stakeholders during the 2026 infrastructure policy catalog process, it is absent from the draft roadmap.

Clean Coalition supports CAISO's planned implementation of FERC Order No. 1920 and the scheduled update to the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between CAISO, the California Energy Commission, and the California Public Utilities Commission. Although CAISO already considers non-transmission alternatives in its Transmission Planning Process (TPP), these efforts should establish a more comprehensive framework for identifying, evaluating, and implementing DER portfolios as cost-effective alternatives to transmission investments. Rather than evaluating only individual resources, CAISO should work with the CPUC, CEC, and utilities to proactively assess coordinated portfolios of distributed generation, energy storage, demand response, Virtual Power Plants (VPPs), and Community Microgrids.

Clean Coalition further recommends that CAISO address persistent interconnection and deliverability barriers through its planned Interconnection Process Enhancements (IPE) initiatives. In particular, additional reforms are needed to provide viable pathways for existing energy-only resources to obtain deliverability, including where targeted network upgrades are necessary. Although IPE 5.0 created a limited pathway for operational energy-only projects to seek deliverability, it did not establish a pathway for these resources to obtain deliverability where additional network upgrades are necessary. These barriers are particularly consequential for front-of-meter (FOM) energy storage in local capacity-constrained areas.

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.
3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

Clearway Energy Group
Submitted 11/16/2026, 04:19 pm

Contact

Jack Watson (jack.watson@clearwayenergy.com)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Clearway is supportive of the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap and the CAISO’s continued focus on the policy changes needed to enable clean energy infrastructure development. Clearway supports the proposed Interconnection Process Enhancements (IPE) 6.0 initiative and offers comments on its scope.  

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Clearway has sufficient resources and capacity to actively participate in several of the identified policy initiatives in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap. ? 

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

The IPE 6.0 initiative presents an opportunity to review and remedy issues that have emerged since the overhaul of the interconnection process in IPE 2023. Clearway recommends that IPE 6.0 include opportunities for stakeholder input and policy development related to three main topics: refinements to the TPD allocation process, LSE commercial interest points, and CAISO’s role in affected system studies.  

 

Topic 1: Refinements to the TPD allocation process 

  1. TPD durability and transparency at intake: 

Projects seeking deliverability may enter only in zones where TPD is shown available at intake, and Cluster 15+ projects that do not receive an allocation cannot convert to Energy Only. However, intake-stage TPD can be substantially reduced before a cluster’s first allocation through allocations to prior clusters, the operational Energy Only pathway, long lead-time resources TPD reservations, and transmission plan changes such as the cancellation of Del Amo–Mesa–Serrano in the 2025-2026 Transmission Plan. The CAISO should (i) publish intake-stage TPD by zone and POI net of known prior claims, with the method documented; (ii) update it at defined points before the cluster’s first allocation; and (iii) where zonal TPD falls materially after intake for reasons outside the customer’s control, allow penalty-free withdrawal or an Energy Only option. 

  1. Release of TPD reserved for long lead-time (LLT) resources: 

The IPE 2023 Track 3 provisions allow TPD to be reserved for long lead-time resources identified in the transmission plan but set no term after which unused reservations return to the general pool. CAISO’s Cluster 16 guidance does not include a mechanism for expiration or release of the reserved TPD. Clearway recommends that CAISO set objective milestones tied to each TPD reservation’s expected in-service date, such as an executed contract or central procurement award by a defined date. If those milestones are missed, unused TPD should be released to the next allocation cycle. The CAISO could develop these criteria with the CPUC through the MOU update and the transmission planning process. 

  1. GIA execution after the first TPD allocation: 

Projects seeking TPD must execute GIAs and take on financial obligations without knowing whether they will receive a TPD allocation. Clearway supports LSA’s proposal to tender and execute GIAs after the first TPD allocation cycle, with E&P agreements and full security for shared upgrades that must proceed sooner. The GIA execution issue is especially ripe as it will affect Cluster 15 in 2027; Clearway recommends that CAISO create an expedited track including this timing adjustment. 

  1. Merchant zone to TPD zone transition: 

When a Transmission Plan upgrade converts a merchant zone to a TPD zone, the new capacity can sit unused for years. East of Pisgah was a merchant zone in Cluster 15, where projects seeking FCDS had to proceed as merchant requests with fully at-risk upgrade costs. After Board approval of the Trout Canyon – Lugo 500 kV line in the 2025-2026 Transmission Plan, East of Pisgah became a TPD zone for Cluster 16, more than a year later. Clearway recommends that CAISO commit to a schedule for incorporating the most recent Board-approved Transmission Plan into a zonal TPD data and merchant/TPD zone designations used for each cluster window, ideally sequencing study updates to provide final data at least 90 days before a cluster window opens. Clearway recognizes and acknowledges the challenges in aligning studies and processes among the Transmission Plan, Cluster reassessment studies, TPD allocation, and new cluster windows, but improving this process is necessary to ensure that TPD, once available, can be used as quickly as possible to meet California’s clean energy and reliability needs. 

 

Topic 2: LSE commercial interest points 

 

In Clearway’s experience with the Cluster 15 and Cluster 16 application windows, LSE commercial interest points have been a significant inefficiency in the cluster intake process. When the IPE 2023 reforms were finalized, CAISO communicated an expectation to LSEs that “the LSE allocation process is not intended to result in the exchange of value or have terms.” [1] However, in practice most LSEs now ask developers to make commitments, including deposits that go at risk, early in development, when projects have limited cost and schedule information. Clearway recommends that CAISO consider refinements to the points allocation process and guidance provided to LSEs within the IPE 6.0 initiative, to provide clarity and value to LSEs as well as queue entrants and to reduce the downstream cost impact to ratepayers. For example, through the MOU update, the CAISO and CPUC could convene a workshop with LSEs and developers well in advance of the Cluster 17 window (ideally more than 6 months) to review the Cluster 16 experience, including the timing of LSE solicitations relative to available study information, the consistency of LSE requirements, and the cumulative cost impact of LSEs’ financial security requirements. 

 

[1] Final Addendum to IPE 2023 Final Proposal, June 6, 2024. 

 

Topic 3: Affected Systems Coordination 

 

Many of the CAISO’s neighboring affected systems are not FERC-jurisdictional, so FERC Order No. 2023’s affected system requirements do not reach them. Affected system study timelines remain a significant source of delay for projects with executed GIAs. Clearway recommends that the IPE 6.0 initiative includes consideration of actions the CAISO could take to improve the efficiency of the affected systems study process for Interconnection Customers. While CAISO does not control when affected systems perform their studies, Clearway specifically recommends the following enhancements: 

  1. Interim operating solutions within the CAISO system, such as operating procedures, temporary RAS or Limited Operation, that let a project reach commercial operation while affected system upgrades are pending; 

  1. A standing forum or working group to coordinate affected system studies for each cluster by study area. 

EDFps
Submitted 11/16/2026, 04:50 pm

Submitted on behalf of
EDFps

Contact

Raeann Quadro (rquadro@gridwell.com)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

EDF power solutions (EDFps) supports the roadmap’s focus on improving interconnection, transmission planning, and timely infrastructure development. We appreciate CAISO’s inclusion of operational battery augmentation in IPE 6.0 and its recognition that interconnection and deliverability processes must align with Order No. 1920 implementation. However, the final roadmap should more clearly address outstanding stakeholder requests and provide an urgent path for resolving policy questions emerging through implementation of the Resource Interconnection Standards (RIS).

Operational battery augmentation

EDFps supports addressing streamlined augmentation of operational batteries through IPE 6.0. Our May comments requested clear criteria for like-for-like replacements, screening thresholds, timely review, and guidance distinguishing Permissible Technological Advancements (PTAs) from changes requiring a Material Modification Assessment (MMA).

The initiative should expressly address routine augmentation that maintains existing capability within studied parameters. Battery degradation continues while these procedures are being developed, and lengthy modification reviews can impair a resource’s ability to maintain contracted capacity and duration. EDFps also reiterates its request for information on historical PTA determinations to help stakeholders understand existing practices and identify opportunities for improvement.

Interconnection and Order No. 1920 alignment

EDFps appreciates CAISO’s indication that alignment of interconnection and Order No. 1920 will be addressed through compliance and BPM processes, consistent with the MOU. CAISO should clarify the scope, stakeholder engagement opportunities, and schedule for this work, including where it will address EDFps’ concerns about interconnection study assumptions, deliverability allocation opportunities, and queue intake across planning cycles.

EDFps is open to addressing these concerns within an existing process, provided that process allows substantive stakeholder discussion and any necessary policy development. The final roadmap should make that path explicit.

Affected System coordination

EDFps’ May comments requested a stakeholder effort on Affected System coordination, but the draft roadmap does not identify a disposition or work plan for that request.

The concerns remain: uncertain study timelines, changing assumptions and mitigation requirements, inconsistent coordination, and late-stage or post-commercial-operation mitigation requests. EDFps requests an explicit response and a defined opportunity to consider improvements, including study transparency, proportionality, finality, and dispute resolution. A voluntary regional working group could provide a practical starting point while respecting neighboring systems’ authority and reliability responsibilities. If CAISO declines to scope this work now, it should retain the request for future consideration and explain when it will be revisited.

Urgent resolution of RIS implementation policy questions

The final roadmap should expressly provide for resolution of outstanding RIS policy questions through IPE 6.0 or a dedicated, accelerated stakeholder effort. These questions affect current projects and financial commitments; they cannot be addressed solely as prospective improvements for Cluster 17.

EDFps continues to distinguish three categories of issues:

  • Errors in draft BPM language: Incorrect references to GIDAP, the Independent Study Process, and other provisions that require correction or updating.
  • Interpretation and guidance items: Questions about how existing tariff provisions operate, including deposit timing and credits, refund eligibility, commercial viability requirements, and the criteria for determining whether a withdrawal has a material impact. These are appropriate for BPM clarification where the guidance remains within the tariff.
  • Substantive requirements needing a clear policy and tariff basis: Requirements that appear to add to or change Appendix KK obligations, including increased withdrawal-penalty security, its treatment alongside construction funding, and the resulting cumulative financial exposure.

For the third category, EDFps is asking substantive policy questions about what customers must secure, what they may forfeit, and what protections apply. These questions require an identified policy rationale and tariff basis, with further stakeholder discussion and tariff revisions where necessary.

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

EDFps intends to participate actively in the initiatives most directly affecting resource development and operation, particularly IPE 6.0, battery augmentation, transmission planning alignment, and resolution of outstanding RIS implementation questions.

Stakeholder capacity is finite. Clear scopes, coordinated schedules, timely written materials, and substantive responses to comments will help EDFps participate effectively. Repeatedly raising the same unresolved questions across ICUG, BPM review sessions, and policy initiatives consumes resources without providing the certainty needed for project decisions.

Making substantive policy changes through compliance filings without a corresponding stakeholder discussion limits stakeholder understanding and misses the opportunity to draw on the collective expertise of CAISO, PTOs, developers, and other participants. Compliance obligations may establish required outcomes while leaving consequential choices about policy design and implementation that benefit from open discussion.

CAISO has successfully used dedicated stakeholder initiatives to develop compliance-driven changes, including:

  • FERC Order No. 764 market changes: Development of the fifteen-minute market and intra-hour scheduling framework.
  • FERC Order No. 831—Import Bidding and Market Parameters: Stakeholder development of import bid cost verification and related market pricing rules.
  • FERC Order No. 1000 compliance, Phases 1 and 2: Stakeholder development of regional and interregional transmission planning, cost allocation, and competitive transmission development provisions.

These precedents demonstrate that compliance and collaborative policy development can proceed together. EDFps requests a comparable opportunity to work through the interaction between Order No. 2023 compliance and IPE reforms, resolve outstanding policy questions, and establish a shared understanding before customers face consequential financial commitments.

A coordinated working process involving CAISO policy, tariff, implementation, and legal staff, together with PTOs and stakeholders, makes bets use of all resources. 

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

EDFps supports the proposed single intake process and clearer coordination among infrastructure and market policy work. The process should also provide a transparent disposition for each stakeholder request: included, assigned to an existing process, deferred, or declined. Where a request is assigned elsewhere, CAISO should identify the responsible forum, scope, and anticipated schedule. Deferred requests should remain visible for future consideration because deferral does not resolve the underlying problem.

Most urgently, CAISO needs a workable escalation path for policy questions identified during implementation.

Stakeholders have raised RIS concerns through both the BPM Proposed Revision Request process and the Interconnection Customer User Group (ICUG). CAISO staff have declined substantive discussion on the grounds that the PRR process is not a forum for policy debate and ICUG is not a forum for discussing the BPM or hypothetical applications. EDFps understands the limits of those forums. However, those limits make it necessary for CAISO to provide an appropriate policy forum.

If CAISO does not believe these are policy questions, it should convene discussions explaining its interpretation and identifying the provisions that answer stakeholders’ questions. Stating that a requirement reflects existing policy does not resolve questions about what that policy requires or how the tariff supports it.

EDFps appreciates the additional RIS BPM review sessions. Nevertheless, stakeholders lack a clear, dependable schedule for a revised draft BPM and resolution of the disputed provisions. Removing disputed language from a draft, or deferring discussion to another forum, does not establish the requirements customers will face.

Cluster 15 projects are approaching GIA and funding decisions, while Cluster 16 projects are approaching study commencement and withdrawal-penalty exposure. Customers need to understand their obligations and potential liability before making those decisions. The roadmap should recognize this implementation work as an immediate priority and allocate the resources needed to complete it.

San Diego Gas & Electric
Submitted 10/30/2026, 10:55 am

Contact

Pamela Mills (pmills@sdge.com)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Voting “support” indicates that your organization largely agrees with both the selection of market policy initiative topics and the proposed schedules for these initiatives. Voting “oppose” indicates that your organization largely opposes the selection of market policy initiatives topics and the proposed schedules for these initiatives

 

Support.

SDG&E largely agrees with the selection of policy initiative topics. However, we offer the following specific feedback on the selection and timing given CAISO’s ambitious scope:

  • SDG&E urges CAISO to adhere to its commitments and proposed timeline for the CRRE initiative. Given the continued delays, SDG&E is frustrated that the initiative has yet to provide a meaningful opportunity to discuss and evaluate solutions to longstanding concerns with the CRR auction design.
  • SDG&E also supports a timely decision and implementation of an EDAM CRA solution by Q3 2027 in order to fully support integration of EDAM and pre-EDAM entities congestion revenue policies. Both CRRE and CRA are high priority initiatives for SDG&E.
  • SDG&E supports the update to PFE in the roadmap to reflect that there will be no October 2026 decision. However, the topics within this initiative are complex, and many stakeholders, including SDG&E, do not believe comprehensive scarcity pricing is needed at this moment, nor should be a priority in the near term. Accordingly, SDG&E does not support a Q4 2027 decision timeline for a PFE proposal that includes comprehensive scarcity pricing, especially given the volume of issues CAISO plans to undertake. SDG&E’s participation in other initiatives could be hindered by the current schedule if major reforms for scarcity pricing remains a focus. SDG&E continues to have tentative support for more targeted areas of the draft proposal pending additional analysis and does not oppose these being included in the catalog, but if resources are limited supports prioritizing other initiatives.  
  • SDG&E generally supports the SDM initiative and timeline but notes that there has been limited discussion of uplift in Track 2 thus far, and it is unlikely that this aspect of the initiative will be ready for a decision by Q1 2027. SDG&E suggests that CAISO update the roadmap accordingly. SDG&E also asks that CAISO explicitly include the non-linearity solution in the Topic Group 1 description to clearly indicate that implementation of this completed policy discussion is expected in Q3 2027.
  • SDG&E believes the CAISO should extend the timeline for Track 2 of the RAMPD initiative, moving a Board decision to at least Q2 2027. SDG&E believes the proposed timeline is too ambitious, as significant questions remain and stakeholders have yet to reach agreement on several elements of the proposal, given the complexity of the issues. SDG&E also strongly supports inclusion of Track 5, MIC enhancements, on the roadmap.
  • SDG&E supports the inclusion of EDAM enhancements on an “as-needed” basis in the roadmap, which provides CAISO flexibility to address emerging or immediate needs as they arise.
  • SDG&E notes that DDEMI now includes a Large Loads focus and is concerned that the various tracks of this initiative could grow into significant overlapping workloads and cautions against expanding scope beyond what can reasonably be completed on this timeline.
2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

Voting “support” indicates that your organization has the necessary resources to fully participate in relevant stakeholder initiatives within the timeline outlined in the draft market policy roadmap. Voting “oppose” indicates that your organization does not expect to be able to fully participate in relevant stakeholder initiatives within the timeline outlined in the draft market policy roadmap.

Oppose.

SDG&E notes several concerns with overlapping initiative phases and their impact on stakeholder workload and the ability to meaningfully engage in policy development. With fifteen initiatives on the roadmap, many involving multiple phases and complex subject areas, the overall volume of work may limit SDG&E’s (and other stakeholders’) ability to provide the level of engagement necessary to fully inform policy development. SDG&E therefore offers the following specific suggestions and urges CAISO to remain flexible and responsive to stakeholder feedback on initiative timing and sequencing throughout the year.

  • CAISO should sequence the start of RAMPD Track 5 (MIC Enhancements) so that it does not run concurrently with RAMPD Track 2. Staggering these efforts would help ensure sufficient stakeholder capacity to meaningfully engage in both initiatives.
  • Delay the RAMPD Track 2 expected decision date by at least one quarter
  • Remove Flex RA from the scope of RAMPD. SDG&E does not view Flex RA as an immediate priority, particularly given the already ambitious scope of the initiative.
  • Given that PFE is a lower priority item for SDG&E, we believe the policy development and decision for this initiative (specifically Comprehensive Scarcity Pricing Reform) can be postponed such that stakeholders can focus on higher priority items.
3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

SDG&E appreciates the schedule adjustments CAISO has made to provide additional time for stakeholder engagement and analysis. However, SDG&E is concerned with the use of “no sooner than” terminology during the October 1 stakeholder meeting, as it does not provide a clear implementation timeline or expectation. Greater certainty around anticipated implementation dates is important for stakeholders to effectively plan staffing and workload, as well as prepare for necessary process and system updates associated with policy and BRS changes. SDG&E encourages CAISO to provide more defined implementation expectations.

State Water Contractors
Submitted 11/16/2026, 12:06 pm

Contact

Jonathan Young (jyoung@swc.org)

1. Describe your organization’s support for the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

The State Water Contractors (SWC) is a nonprofit association of 27 public water agencies that receive water from the State Water Project (SWP). The SWP is one of California’s largest electricity users, and its CAISO transmission costs ultimately flow to SWC members and the roughly 27 million Californians and 750,000 acres of farmland they serve. SWC appreciates the opportunity to comment.

SWC is disappointed the roadmap omits the Transmission Access Charge (TAC) Structure Enhancements proposed by the California Department of Water Resources (DWR), and we continue to support that proposal for the reasons we have previously stated.

Other stakeholders have likewise expressed support for the initiative or acknowledged that TAC reform aligns with other ratemaking activities. For example, in its May comments, the CPUC suggested that retail rate design changes be coordinated with High-Voltage (HV) TAC reform to ensure an equitable allocation of transmission costs to ratepayers. SWC agrees, as its members are both retail and wholesale ratepayers.

At the October 15 meeting, CAISO staff said it is monitoring CPUC ratemaking proposals around retail rate design. SWC asks CAISO to identify what outcome in that proceeding would lead it to take up TAC enhancements.

Additionally, CAISO staff indicated they would be developing educational materials to better inform stakeholders as to why the existing structure is sufficient. SWC would request that CAISO staff allow stakeholders to provide feedback on the materials prior to finalizing.

2. Please indicate whether your organization has the resources and capacity to support participation in the portfolio of policy initiatives outlined in the draft 2027-2029 infrastructure policy roadmap.

SWC has the capacity to participate in the portfolio of policy initiatives and looks forward to reviewing the TAC white paper.

3. Please provide process feedback where applicable, including on the proposed 2027 roadmap process.

SWC offers the following process feedback:

  • Under the proposed single intake, CAISO should inform submitters early which path their proposal is assigned to and why.  
  • If the Roadmaps are to include stakeholder prioritization, SWC would suggest that each priority level is assigned a number of points, for example: high priority – 5 points, moderate priority 3 points, low priority 1 point. Allocating points would better illustrate the levels of support for initiatives.  

SWC appreciates CAISO’s consideration of these comments.

Back to top